The Spirit Thief by Rachel Aaron

I found this one to be a bit of a mixed bag. The magic system was interesting and the characters were intriguing, but the story itself just did not live up to my somewhat lofty expectations.

Spirit Thief

Basically spirits inhabit everything. The ink in your pen, the door to your jail cell, that candle over there, your pants, and… I guess even your excrement? It’s not really clear where the spirits start and stop. Hmmm, I might be over-thinking that one a bit. Anyway, these spirits inhabit everything and you can perform magic by convincing these spirits to do stuff for you. You can make the fire spirit burn stuff or make the wind spirit blow things around and so on and so forth. The evil mages enslave them, the decent-enough mages convince the spirits to work for them, and then there is Eli Monpress. He charms spirits on the spot to do things for him with his tremendous ability to sweet-talk the spirits. And no, disappointingly there is no scene where he sweet-talks his faeces into doing anything (yet alone dancing). Missed opportunity.

Eli Monpress

I do really like this artwork of Eli. It captures his look and personality perfectly.

Eli is a charming and witty thief/magician who preforms outlandish feats of thievery and crime. His main aim is to increase the bounty on his head and he has a friend called Josef helping him who is highly skilled with a blade and has an immensely powerful sword. At first you think these two will be the main show but then Miranda comes along with her massive dog and just craps on everything. She steals the show, but not really in a good way. She’s the boring goodie-good who is sent to take down Eli but then has to team up with him to defeat the King’s evil brother. I groaned when I discovered how prominently she was going to feature in Eli’s story – in fact she is basically the main character as I think she features in the story far more than Eli does.

The story itself is quite interesting but didn’t really capitalize on Eli’s abilities or the potential of the magic system. Maybe the other books in the trilogy do? For example, Eli is really built up in terms of his legendary ability to do mischief but in the end he doesn’t really get up to much in the way of grand scheming. You can also tell that he is meant to be really witty but the writing fails in this regard. Instead of having him say something clever he just winks and smiles cheekily and this is used multiple times by the author to try and communicate to you that this is what Eli is like. It has the subtlety of nails being tapped slowly into your eyeballs.

In the end the spirits felt a lot like Pokemon. You catch them and summon them. Some are more powerful than others. And then at the end there is the almighty great spirit (that’s the ultra rare sparkly Pokemon).

I enjoyed this book just enough to move on to the second one as I think there is some great potential. Here’s hoping things only get better from here!

Have you read this series? Do the books get better as the series goes on?




8 thoughts on “The Spirit Thief by Rachel Aaron

  1. Pokemon notwithstanding I don’t think I like the idea of having nails slowly tapped into my eyes *shivers*. I did buy this book ages ago and still haven’t picked it up. To be honest I’m not convinced to bump it up the pile.
    Lynn 😀

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Hello, I haven’t read this book but it sounds to me like the magic system may have problems with it. I find that if there are so many spirits for everything it makes problem solving too easy, such as you are in jail so “charm” the door open. If it was as easy as that for every problem then you would have to make the “charming” process as entertaining as possible. It’s almost like The Force in Star Wars which is the opposite and is all encompassing. Even a fan like me can get a little bored when a situation resolves itself because “the Force wills it.” etc. Then if the magician is usurped as the story’s main character, it does sound as if the book is a little “clunky”. If I see a copy I might try reading it. Thanks for the review.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. To say the truth, my two encounters with this author (either as Rachel Aaron or Rachel Bach – depending on the genre, probably) have not turned out as well as I hoped: her stories are nice, quite readable and entertaining, but still I feel as if something is missing. On the other hand, that could very well be my fault, even though I sense some of my own lack of enthusiasm in your word as well…

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I sort of smiled hard at the Pokemon comparison by the end of the review hahaha Not sure I’d want to try this one, but I did love the honesty in your review. Spirits in absolutely everything material is a bit of a scary thought though. Hmm… 🤣

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s